European Network of Health Care Chaplaincy
The 9th Consultation, Lisbon, Portugal
17-21 May 2006
"Building Bridges -
Growing Hope"
Coordinator’s Report
Six years ago in Crete, the European Network of Health Care Chaplaincy was
officially formed. I say “officially” because for 10 years, national
representatives of chaplaincies had been meeting every two years to share
their experiences. In Crete, 23 representatives took part in the
Consultation. The fact that 54 official representatives have joined together
here in Lisbon verifies that the Network has indeed reached a high level of
recognition and acceptance on both an international, European, national and
Faith level.
In Crete, the question posed was whether or not a united chaplaincy could be
established within a European context. After six years of hard work and
careful planning, this consultation shows that we have overcome many
barriers, that we have built many bridges and that we have truly grown into
a higher level of maturity, a growth that gives us hope. In Turku, during
our 7th Consultation, the Standards for Health Care Chaplaincy were adopted.
In Dublin, during our 8th Consultation, we tried to pinpoint the tensions of
European Chaplaincy on five levels: 1) the level of ecumenical dialogue; 2)
the level of intra-church relations; 3) the level of multi-cultural issues;
4) the level of multi-disciplinary cooperation; 5) the level of the state
(local, national and European). It was also during the Dublin Consultation
that we adopted the Constitution of the ENHCC. It is also worthy to note
that the President of Ireland officially opened our meeting. The aim of
this, the 9th Consultation of the ENHCC, is to stabilize the bridges we have
built over the past years and to try to find ways of bringing our
chaplaincies even closer together on a more practical level.
This Consultation, though, would not have been possible without the support
and hospitality of the Coordenação Nacional Capelanias Hospitalares,
particularly of its National Director Fr. Nuno Ferreira da Silva. Fr. Nuno’s
presence in the ENHCC over the past two years has been a dynamic one, full
of energy, with a firm belief and commitment to the “Idea” of the European
Network. I would also like to thank Fr. Vito Pinto of Portugal, who is the
European Coordinator of Pastoral Health Care for the Roman Catholic Church,
for his support throughout the whole organization of this consultation. Fr.
Vitor’s and Fr. Nuno’s leadership and sincere warmth have been a true force
in bringing us together and I am sure that their genuine love for chaplaincy
will inspire us throughout our stay in Lisbon. Without genuine love, we, as
chaplains, will fall short of being vessels of God’s healing grace. Without
genuine love, we cannot overcome our obstacles; we cannot build bridges
between our borders; our hope for a well founded chaplaincy will never grow
and each of us will not be able to grow personally in that hope. I am sure
that we will take their warmth and love back home with us and that they will
be a renewing force in continuing our ministry.
In addition to the Chaplaincy of Portugal, I would like to that the
Association of Catholic Health Care Chaplains in German Speaking
Switzerland, and particularly Chaplain Marlène Inauen, for providing the
funds to sponsor two representatives to this Consultation.
One of the most significant bridges that were built during the past two
years is between our Network and the European Union. In leaving Dublin, it
was clear that things had matured enough that we could finally proceed in
making our way into the corridors of the offices of the Commission of the
European Union. This, though, needed careful planning so as our efforts
would be successful. Thanks to the help of the Liaison Office of the
Ecumenical Patriarchate in Brussels, I was able to make contacts with three
persons in key positions: The European Policy Advisor on Dialogue with
Religions, Churches and Humanism, the Commissioner of Public Health and the
Vice-President of the EU Parliament. After several letters and telephone
calls, meetings were finally scheduled with these officials in June of 2005.
(A detailed report of these meeting will be given during the following
session of our Consultation). Here, I will only state that the meetings were
successful in that we opened a direct line of communication with all three
offices.
During our meeting with the Director of the Office of the Commissioner of
Public Health, an unexpected proposal was made which will allow us to create
closer ties with his office and to build a new bridge with the medical
community. We were informed that the Commissioner is very concerned about
viewing the way palliative care is being handled in the European Union. He
asked if we could contribute to a study of recommendations that was being
done on this issue. In fact, after our meeting, I received a phone call
asking that I meet with the person who was writing up the study. Indeed, Ms.
Akylledis flew to Athens to meet with me where we had a two and a half hour
meeting. At the end of our meeting, she asked that I make direct suggestions
to the written report. After this meeting and the suggestions made, the
Commissioner’s office called and thanked the ENHCC for its impute. At this
point, the study and recommendations of palliative care are still in the
hands of the Commissioner, but this issue holds a series of future prospects
for the ENHCC on many levels. It is a significant and specialized part of
spiritual health care which brings us as chaplains in contact with the
medical community and the official administration of health care facilities
and policy makers. As a result of this development, we now are in a position
where we can play a major role in this area on a EU level. For this reason,
we will have a special session during this consultation on palliative care,
coordinated by Rev. David Mitchell from Scotland, with the hope that we will
be able to agree on a “statement on palliative care” at the conclusion of
our discussion.
One of the other main bridges that have been built over the past few years
has been with the American Association of Professional Chaplaincy. In March
of 2005, the ENHCC took part in the Annual Joint Conference of the
Association of Professional Chaplains and the National Association of
Catholic Chaplains which took place in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Chaplain
Anne Vandenhoeck, Representative of the Chaplaincy of Belgium and a member
of the Network Committee, was our representative at this important event.
There, she met with leaders of the APC and the NACC, establishing even
firmer relations between our organizations and reiterating our desire to see
how our chaplaincies could establish closer working relations. As an
expression of sharing this desire, in their journal, the APC published the
letter with our greetings to their conference. Today, here in Lisbon, we are
most privileged to have two important people who have played a significant
role in establishing a bridge over the Atlantic: Ms. Josephine Schrader,
Executive Director of the APC, who is representing all the conjoint
Chaplaincies of North America and Rev. George Burn. Ms. Schrader has
enthusiastically embraced the idea of forming a closer relationship between
our organizations and she will be speaking to us during a special session.
Rev. Burn has actually been the “voice of America” in the Eurochaplains
yahoo group, writing messages, expressing concerns, provoking stimulating
dialogue, offering encouragement and support, wishes and many prayers. Their
participation here in Lisbon is historic in that we will have the first
opportunity that I know of in which the Chaplaincies of our two great
continents can sit down and discuss how we can share our experience and
ability on a concrete level.
Besides our growing relationship with the APC and the NACC in North America,
over the past two years we also established official relations with the
CAPPE/ACPEP (Canadian Association for Pastoral Practice and Education) and
the Professional Association for Spiritual Care and Health (PASCH) in Japan.
Our relations with the Church & Society Commission Conference of European
Churches remain standing as we are officially informed of its meetings (as
you may have seen in previous e-mails, particularly on issues related to
bioethics). Dr. Richard Fischer
Executive Secretary of the Commission has requested that we meet with him in
the future.
Three publications regarding the Network helped build bridges in different
directions. The Southern Journal of Medicine of the USA will be publishing
any day now an issue in which spiritual health care will be examined. I was
asked to write an article on “Chaplaincy in Europe” for this publication
and, in a separate article, the Euro Standards for Health Care Chaplaincy
will be present. This is a bridge toward the medical community. Chaplain
Anne Vandenhoeck, who was asked to become a member of the Advisory Board of
the periodical “Plain Views – A Publication of the Healthcare Chaplaincy”,
was asked to write an article which was entitled “A Challenge for the
European Network of Health Care Chaplains”. This is a bridge toward fellow
chaplains throughout the world. The Scottish Journal of Pastoral Care
published the paper that was presented to the officials of the EU with the
title “Spiritual Health Care and the European Union” (Volume 8 No. 2,
October 2005). This is a bridge toward a chaplaincy and a publication that
is exemplary for us all.
Here I may add that in August of 2005, I attended the European Conference of
Pastoral Care and Counselling in Sweden. This gave me an opportunity to meet
many chaplains throughout Europe and people that were involved in pastoral
care. Thanks to our beloved Network Committee member, Rev. Kirsti Aalto, who
was then President of the ECPCC (European Council of Pastoral Care and
Counselling), I was able to present our Network to all the participants
during one of the sessions. At this important event, I made contact with
Ursula Pfäfflin, President of the International Council of Pastoral Care and
Counselling, who is joining us today here in Lisbon as an observer. At the
conclusion of the Sweden event, Fr. Adamantios Augustidis, who has been a
long standing representative to the ENHCC, was elected President of the
European Council. His presence here in Lisbon, together with Ms. Pfäfflin’s,
will allow us to join our efforts in establishing united efforts in the area
of chaplaincy and pastoral care at large.
What though is most encouraging is that we as a Network have grown within!
This is indeed what is most important! As I stated, we have reached a point
of growth that truly gives us hope! In planning this Consultation, the
Network Committee told Fr. Nuno that no more than 40 to 45 representatives
would probably come. We have over surpassed ourselves! In Crete, 22 official
organizations took part in that historic consultation. Today, here in
Lisbon, we have reached the landmark of 46 official organizations that take
part the ENHCC. The new participants in our Network are the:
(1) Department of German Catholic Bishops' Conference
(2) Patriarchate of Moscow
(3) Lutheran Evangelical Church of Slovakia
(4) Pastoral Healthcare Department, Episcopal Conference of Spain
(Roman Catholic)
(5) Association of Swiss Protestant German Speaking Chaplains (We have been
in contact but this is the first time they have been at a consultation in
recent years - since 2000)
(6) Association of Hospice and Palliative Care Chaplains in UK
(7) Metropolitan Commission for Pastoral Health Care (Ukraine)
(8) Orthodox Church of Albania
(9) Reactivated link with Denmark (Danish Association of Chaplains in
Healthcare)
Allow me to officially welcome all of you and I am sure that your presence
in the Network will enrich us in many ways.
This brings us to a very important issue which we hopefully will be facing
throughout our deliberations here in Lisbon. How can we as a Network of
European Chaplaincy work closer together in building bridges amongst
ourselves? For this is the reason for our Network’s existence and if we do
not answer this question we will fail! This past October, the Network
Committee met in Istanbul at the Ecumenical Patriarchate for our annual
meeting. One of the main issues we discussed was how the participants of the
Network could increase sharing their experience and knowledge with the other
participants. One of the main reasons for our existence is that we have all
realized that we cannot remain isolated in our own Chaplaincies,
particularly is a world where cultures are meeting, overlapping, and trying
to integrate in a way of life which is “multi” in character. In today’s
world, Chaplaincies not be self-sufficient. As I wrote to you shortly after
our departure from Dublin, “Two are better than one, because they have a
good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up the other;
but woe to one who is alone and falls and does not have another to help.
(Eccles. 4:9-10)”. So it is that in Istanbul, it was decided that a special
session would be held during our meeting here in Lisbon to find concrete
ways of building firmer bridges of exchange and support amongst our
organizations.
During the past two years, two Chaplaincies took a leading role in this
effort: the Latvia Association of Professional Health Care Chaplaincy (LPVAKA)
and the Protestant Hospital Chaplaincy of France. Both of these
organizations dealt with chaplaincy in a “European perspective”, inviting
representatives from other chaplaincies to speak. Fr. Adamantios Augustidis
and Chaplain Anne Vandenhoeck spoke in Latvia and Rev. Kirsti Aalto and Fr.
Angelo Brusco spoke in France.
In an effort to promote interrelations been our chaplaincies, ENHCC
greetings were sent to national chaplaincy conferences that took place in
Ireland (where they celebrated their silver anniversary), France, Finland,
Latvia, the Roman Catholic Chaplaincy of Germany, and the Pontifical
Conference for Palliative Care.
The main source of sharing for the Network has been and remains to be the
ENHCC Website. Thanks to the dedication, talent and continual inspiration of
our devoted webmaster, Rev. Fred Coutts, our web site has won praise from
all over the world. Without him and his genuine interest in communicating
with us all, our Network would not have grown the way it has. Special thanks
and applause should be given to our webmaster!!!
Over the past two years, we attempted to form an ENHCC electronic library to
allow for academic sharing. Chaplain Anne Vandenhoeck was asked to take a
lead in this effort. Unfortunately, this effort has not blossomed as we
hoped. This is something we can talk about in our upcoming sessions.
The Committee signalled out two areas we need to deal with in order to help
us all form a better understanding of each other and foster further
relations. One is to develop a better understanding of our theological
perspectives in relation to the way we provide spiritual care and the way
our Chaplaincies are structured. The other is to try to see how the
multi-cultural issue in chaplaincy is dealt with on a very practical basis.
(This was something that the officials of the EU challenged us on this past
June). As you will notice, two separate sessions during our Consultation
will be devoted to these issues.
Lastly, the legal status of the Network must be discussed. As most of you
remember, during our last consultation in Dublin, we adopted our first
Constitution. In itself, this constitution did not have any real legality
outside of our own organization. It was necessary to legalize our
organization under a legal system of a European country. In order to do
this, the Network Committee authorized me to proceed and legalize the
Network under Greek law, using our “Dublin” Constitution as a basis. This
was done and we now are an official non-profit making organization. As a
result we were able to open a bank account in our name. The Network
Committee appointed Rev. Derek Brown to help in keeping track of our
financial standing. The next step we must take is to become a NGO (Non
Governmental Organization). This will allow us to eventually receive
government grants on a national and/or European level. In our last session,
I will give you a full analysis of our financial standing.
While the members of the Network Committee met in Istanbul this past
October, we were blessed in having an audience with the Ecumenical Patriarch
Bartholomew I. In that meeting, His All-Holiness remarked that our mission
as spiritual health care providers is to be an expression of God’s
philanthropy which “does not know geographical boundaries, does not
distinguish race, people or language, but is directed indiscriminately and
without exception to all men and women, who are created in God’s image, as
God Himself.” The Patriarch’s remarks have a very deep meaning for us all.
Whether we are involved in the provision of care, rehabilitation, chaplaincy
or ministry to or with those who have been disabled by suffering and
sickness in a physical, psychological or spiritual way, we must recognize
the central assumptions of equality and dignity within the message of hope
we bear. We are called to proclaim this message of hope at the fore of all
our work, a hope which is deeply rooted in God’s grace. In this aspect, we
are not to be spectators of divine interventions and actions, but co-workers
of His grace. But to become true co-workers of His grace, we must accept one
another, not only as co-workers, but as friends. For, it was He who first
spoke to us as friends (John 17). If our hope is in His love, we must abide
in His love as He has loved us. It is only then that we will truly be an
expression of God’s unlimited and boundless Philanthropy. Hopefully, the
bridges we build during these days in Lisbon will help us, with His
guidance, to cultivate our friendship in and through His love.
Rev. Dr. Stavros Kofinas
Coordinator of the European Network of Healthcare Chaplaincy
(Representative of the Ecumenical Patriarchate)